What to know when choosing a foster care agency that is right for you

Jun 27, 2025

By Rainer S.A. Nisbett, Digital Advertising and Communications Specialist at Cayuga Centers

Congratulations! You’ve made one of the most important first steps — choosing to explore becoming a foster parent. We know this can be incredibly overwhelming, as choosing a foster care agency that’s right for you can make the difference in how you feel supported throughout this process. 

But with so many choices and information out there, how do you know where to start? Or even, how to choose the best foster care agency that truly fits your needs? 

In this article, we’ll guide you through questions to ask and opportunities to consider during this journey. We’ll also share why Cayuga Centers is a top choice for many foster parents — new or experienced.

Why choosing the right foster care agency matters

Becoming a foster parent is a selfless act that shouldn’t be done alone. There will be questions, trainings, new behaviors, and new terminologies to navigate. With anything new, having the guidance of an experienced agency to walk you through this process should be a priority. 

A good agency will provide you with resources, help you anticipate and navigate obstacles, work with your schedule, and offer consistent support to set you up for success. 

Ultimately, choosing a foster care agency means choosing a partnership where the experiences of the youth in foster care, combined with your experience of navigating this new journey, are met with positive outcomes. 

Key questions to ask when choosing an agency

When you’re ready to speak to foster care agencies, ask these questions:

  • What type of foster care does the agency offer? (e.g., Kinship Care, Traditional Foster Care, Treatment Family Foster Care – TFFC, etc.)
  • What are the eligibility requirements?
  • What are the ages of youth that currently need homes?
  • How long does it take to get certified to become a foster parent?
  • What kind of support will I receive? What support with the child in care receive? 
  • Does the agency offer respite care, should I need a short break from caregiving?
  • Does the agency host foster parent support groups?
  • What training is provided before and after certification/licensing?
  • What are the expectations around communication, paperwork, and regulations?

While researching agencies, ask yourself these questions:

  • How responsive are they to your initial request for information and follow-up communications?
  • What credentials does the foster care agency have? Are they accredited? Are they a nonprofit or for profit company?
  • What are other foster parents saying about the agency?
  • Do you feel comfortable with the staff you have spoken to? Do they set realistic expectations?

Answering these questions upfront will help you choose an agency that best aligns with your expectations.

What makes Cayuga Centers stand out

Having been around for over 170 years, Cayuga Centers has built a program uniquely supportive for both children and the families who care for them. Constantly evolving and meeting the needs of the communities served, Cayuga Centers is committed to ensuring that foster parents never feel like they’re on this journey alone.

Foster care doesn’t run on a one-size-fits-all schedule. At Cayuga Centers, foster parents have access to 24/7 support from a dedicated team of professionals who prioritize personal connection and are always a phone call away. 

However, if a foster parent ever finds themselves in a situation where a break is needed from their youth or even if a supportive word is needed from a peer in the same situation, Cayuga Centers offers respite opportunities and support groups.

With a track record of supporting families for over 170 years, foster parents at Cayuga Centers know they can rely on guidance, open communication, and a responsive team that understands what it takes to be a foster parent.

Your foster parent journey: What comes next

With an agency in mind — or hopefully officially chosen — you’re ready to begin your foster care journey.

At Cayuga Centers, we guide you through each step with clarity:

  • Information session to deepen your understanding of what it means to become a foster parent
  • Training and licensure to fully equip you with the knowledge and tools you’ll need to succeed
  • Ongoing 24/7 support once you’re licensed and caring for youth in your home

Ready to become a foster parent with Cayuga Centers? Find a program near you to learn more about fostering.

Foster Parenting with Cayuga Centers

You don’t have to be perfect to be a perfect foster parent. Your unique background, knowledge, and skills might be exactly what a child needs. All you really need is an open heart and mind, and the willingness to give a short or longer-term home to a child who deserves a better future. Right now, there is a high number of children and youth who need a stable home in order to lead a healthy life.

Seeking diverse homes in Upstate New York, New York City, Pittsburgh, Delaware, and South Florida.

cayuga corner

Providing resources and support for your foster parent journey.

How one art class transformed into a space for healing 

How one art class transformed into a space for healing 

A shift in art education    For many years, Michelle Borgogni, the art teacher at Cayuga Centers, focused on basic elements. These included color theory, art history, styles, shapes, values, and composition. Her teachings helped the children in our care...

read more

follow us on instagram

Whether it’s advocating for human rights, supporting access to education, or standing up for equality, every small action counts.
Fun fact for Presidents’ Day: George Washington was one of the few presidents who didn’t live in the White House—it wasn’t even built yet! 🏛️

stay informed

Four Female and One Male Standing Outside Next To a Get Tested for Covid-19 Sign

News

We have a lot going on at Cayuga Centers.
Keep up to date with our latest news and press releases.

Read Current News →