Olivia’s story: How a new agency is redefining foster care in Allegheny County with a bundled service approach

Mar 26, 2025

By L’Tesha Gamble-Pettis & Michelle Prego-Milewski — Cayuga Centers

Originally Published March 14, 2025 in Pittsburgh City Paper

For youth in foster care, sometimes the littlest victories lead to the biggest success. Take Olivia*, for example—a Pittsburgh teen who, after years of uncertainty, is now thriving thanks to the support of Cayuga Centers, Allegheny County’s newest foster care agency.

Olivia was removed from her biological parents when she was 10. Children often find themselves placed in foster care due to challenges such as neglect, parental substance abuse, or lack of stable housing. Youth can be placed with family members, close friends, a foster family, or a residential facility. Olivia moved from home to home nearly achieving permanency—a forever family—several times but without a lasting match.

Cayuga Centers provides Treatment Family Foster Care (TFFC), a level of foster care for youth who have been through incredibly difficult experiences. When Olivia met the team from Cayuga Centers, she had already been in the system for four years. Breaking the cycle of trauma that a child like Olivia has gone through requires a specialized approach. For over 23 years, Cayuga Centers’ TFFC program has been helping youth in foster care heal from trauma and build skills in order to lead productive and successful lives. 

“We provide a safe space for children to be able to live in the community with a higher level of support in a family setting,”  said Cayuga Centers Clinician Peggy Buckley.

When Olivia was matched with a Cayuga Centers foster family, she was understandably cautious after previous disappointments. But this time, she wasn’t alone in her journey. With the support of her foster family and a team of dedicated professionals, including an in-house Youth Skills Coach, Behavioral Case Planner, and Clinician, Olivia began using the tools the team shared with her and began to feel hopeful.

“She was able to work past her anxiety through weekly individual therapy, and therapy with her foster parents,” Buckley said. “Olivia is doing well in school and with her family. It’s been amazing to see her progress since we started working together.”

Olivia’s journey is an inspiring reminder of how much young people can achieve with the right support system. However, there are still over 1,000 youth in Allegheny County waiting for a safe, loving foster home.

We would love for you to help us support a child just like Olivia. Foster parents with Cayuga Centers must be 21 or over, have a spare bedroom for a child, have a regular source of income, and are subject to a background check. Cayuga Centers does not discriminate on the basis of sex, race, religion, marital status or sexual orientation.

We know not everyone can foster, and that’s okay! You can make an impact by sharing the need for foster parents on social media, becoming an Ambassador, or donating. Don’t forget to say hi if you see us out in public! You can spot us in our orange Cayuga Centers gear!

Since 2022 Cayuga Centers, a provider of Allegheny County Children, Youth, and Families, has been serving the Pittsburgh area as part of a national agency that supports over 17,000 children and families each year. Ready to make a difference? Visit cayugacenters.org/pittsburgh or call us at 412-308-9585 to learn more about becoming a foster parent or to schedule an information session. Join us in providing hope and stability for every child in foster care.

*Names and other identifying details have been changed for privacy reasons

Foster Parenting with Cayuga Centers

You don’t have to be perfect to be a perfect foster parent. Your unique background, knowledge, and skills might be exactly what a child needs. All you really need is an open heart and mind, and the willingness to give a short or longer-term home to a child who deserves a better future. Right now, there is a high number of children and youth who need a stable home in order to lead a healthy life.

Seeking diverse homes in Upstate New York, New York City, Pittsburgh, Delaware, and South Florida.

cayuga corner

Providing resources and support for your foster parent journey.

A True Foster Care Success Story

A True Foster Care Success Story

At just seven years old, Sean had already experienced more instability than most adults face in a lifetime.  When Sean began receiving foster care services at Cayuga Centers, he had already experienced multiple placements. On top of that, he experienced...

read more
Increased Need for Treatment Family Foster Care 

Increased Need for Treatment Family Foster Care 

Across the country, the need for Treatment Family Foster Care (TFFC) is rising. Every day, more and more youth enter the foster care system with emotional, behavioral, or mental health challenges that require specialized support. These young people are...

read more
I’m not mom: what should my foster child call me?

I’m not mom: what should my foster child call me?

By Zoë Hutchinson, Vice President of Communications at Cayuga Centers You have done all the preparation. You found a foster care agency and met the requirements. You took the parenting classes and achieved your foster care license. Now you are ready to begin caring...

read more
How one art class transformed into a space for healing 

How one art class transformed into a space for healing 

A shift in art education    For many years, Michelle Borgogni, the art teacher at Cayuga Centers, focused on basic elements. These included color theory, art history, styles, shapes, values, and composition. Her teachings helped the children in our care...

read more

follow us on instagram

👨‍👩‍👧‍👦 Today, we recognize the vital role families play in nurturing, protecting, and shaping lives. At Cayuga Centers, we’re committed to supporting children, parents, caregivers, and communities through programs that strengthen family bonds and create lasting impact.

stay informed

Four Female and One Male Standing Outside Next To a Get Tested for Covid-19 Sign

News

We have a lot going on at Cayuga Centers.
Keep up to date with our latest news and press releases.

Read Current News →